About Us
Businesses and individuals partner with as their first choice for insurance and financial services
At FirstChoice Insurance Agency, our insurance and financial specialists work together to produce comprehensive and complete programs to assist clients manage the growth and changes that occur in business and in life. As an independent insurance agency, we consult with clients to determine the most appropriate insurance coverage and financial plan to suit their lives.
The confidence, choices and commitment of our staff, the companies we represent and the position we hold in the community is evident in the way we treat our clients and each other.
We want to be your first choice for the insurance services you require to protect yourself, your workers, your property and equipment. The confidence, choices and commitment of our staff, the companies we represent and the position we hold in the community is evident in the way we treat our clients and each other.
Local Ownership — Since 1997, Susan J. Andrews, President and owner of FirstChoice Insurance Agency, has led the team who was recognized by a citizens' vote as "The People's Choice." In the same year, the agency was selected as one of the Best Places to Work in the Fox Valley. Through a series of educational and administrative policies, Andrews developed a culture of trust, training and productivity on which the team thrives and the agency prospers.
Independent Insurance Agency — We are proud to represent many highly rated insurance companies and are ranked among the 20 largest independent insurance agencies in Northeast Wisconsin. The foundation of our long-standing relationships is trust, value and responsiveness. Clients are confident that the superior products we provide reflect our 30-year commitment to the industry and people we serve.
Clients receive a wide range of personal, property, casualty and group benefit products for complete coverage at affordable rates. FirstChoice Insurance Agency professionals will be your first choice for experience, exceptional service and personal attention.
Superior Products — Our wide range of products protect against the unexpected events that can affect your assets and your life. Our long-term partners respond to the needs of our clients with product resources that lead the insurance industry in innovation and effectiveness.
Our key product lines include a wide range of financial services from life insurance, fixed annuities, retirement and estate planning. We offer group health, dental, life and disability plans as well as key employee protection. Our business packages offer commercial auto, equipment, bonding and special risk insurance. When clients need coverage for their homes, autos and boats we are easily their first choice for coverage on any personal items.
