Claims
Skip navigation

After-Hours Catastrophic Claims Contact Information

For Catastrophic Claims Only

In the event that you have had a incident resulting in significant injuries or extreme damage to property, you may use the following telephone numbers after normal business hours to start the claim process.

Please limit your use of these numbers to claims resulting from significant personal injury or property damage severe enough to displace people from a home or workplace. For all other claims, please contact our offices during normal business hours, or use one of our online claim forms.

CompanyContact Number
AAA(800) 289-5255
Acuity(800) 242-7666
Auto Owner's(888) 252-4626
Cincinnati(920) 379-6077 or (920) 420-2690
Foremost(800) 527-3907
Frankenmuth(888) 685-0186
Great Lakes Claims Service
Hagerty(800) 922-4050
Leave message
Mt. Morris(608) 697-3375
Philadelphia(800) 765-9749
Press 3 when prompted
Progressive(800) 776-4737
State Auto(800) 766-1853

Contact Us 24/7

We know that insurance losses don't always happen during normal business hours, and have provided you with this Web-based claim filing feature, so that you may start a claim at any time.

Just fill out the form that applies to your claim and click "submit." One of our professionals will review the form and contact you to finalize the claims submission.

Of course, we would also be happy to walk you through the claims process personally - just call us during business hours, and we'll be happy to help interactively.

 
 
 

Contact Us

FirstChoice Insurance Agency, Inc.
338 Pearl Ave.
Oshkosh, WI 54903-0766
(920) 235-3450, Toll free: (800) 368-7536, FAX: (920) 232-8731
E-Mail: mail@firstchoiceinsurance.biz

Copyright ©2004-2008, FirstChoice Insurance Agency of Wisconsin, Inc.